Bottom Line: What It Costs to Live in St. George
St. George sits at the northern tip of Staten Island, directly across Upper New York Bay from lower Manhattan. The neighborhood is built around the St. George Ferry Terminal — one of the most recognizable transit hubs in the city — and rises steeply up the hillside behind it. Richmond Terrace runs along the waterfront, lined with institutional buildings, parks, and views across to the Manhattan skyline that rank among the most dramatic in the five boroughs.
The neighborhood has been slowly revitalizing over the past decade. The Empire Outlets retail complex and the New York Wheel project (stalled but ongoing) have drawn attention. Cultural institutions including the Staten Island Museum, Snug Harbor Cultural Center (a short distance west), and the St. George Theatre — a beautifully restored 1929 vaudeville house — anchor a modest but genuine arts scene. For a borough often dismissed by Manhattanites, St. George punches above its weight in cultural programming.
Rent & Housing Costs in St. George
| Apartment Type | Monthly Rent Range | Median Estimate |
|---|---|---|
| Studio | $1,100–$1,500 | $1,300 |
| 1 Bedroom | $1,400–$1,900 | $1,650 |
| 2 Bedroom | $1,900–$2,600 | $2,250 |
| 3 Bedroom | $2,400–$3,400 | $2,900 |
St. George's housing stock is a mix of Victorian-era row houses and apartment buildings converted from older residential stock, newer mid-rise rental buildings near the ferry terminal, and some public housing. The hillside terrain means many units have significant views — a genuine selling point at this price level. The rental market here is less competitive than in Manhattan or Brooklyn, which means more negotiating leverage and more time to find the right unit.
What Salary Do You Need to Live in St. George?
The math: Median 1BR rent is approximately $1,650/month. Using the 30% rule, you'd need monthly gross income of about $5,500 — or $66,000/year gross.
At $66,000 in NYC, your estimated take-home (after federal, NY State, and NYC local taxes) is approximately $49,750/year ($4,146/month). Your rent-to-take-home ratio sits around 40% — above ideal, but critical to note: the Staten Island Ferry is free, saving you the cost of a monthly MetroCard ($132/month) if your commute endpoint is near the South Ferry/Whitehall area. That's nearly $1,600/year in transit savings.
For a studio at $1,300/month, a salary of $52,000–$56,000 gross is workable, with take-home around $39,900–$43,200/year.
Monthly Budget Estimate for St. George
| Expense | Estimated Monthly Cost |
|---|---|
| Rent (1BR median) | $1,650 |
| Groceries | $320–$440 |
| Transit (ferry free + subway at Manhattan end) | $0–$132 |
| Utilities (electric, gas) | $80–$140 |
| Dining out | $200–$340 |
| Health & fitness | $50–$110 |
| Personal & misc. | $150–$260 |
| Total Estimate | $2,450–$3,072 |
Transit & Commute from St. George
- Staten Island Ferry (free): Runs 24/7, departing every 30 minutes during off-peak hours and every 15–20 minutes during rush hour. The 25-minute crossing to Whitehall Terminal in lower Manhattan is entirely free — one of the best transit deals in New York City.
- South Ferry/Whitehall subway connections: From the Manhattan ferry terminal, the 1 train (South Ferry) and R/W trains (Whitehall St) connect immediately. Midtown (Times Square) is about 20–25 minutes from South Ferry on the 1 train.
- Staten Island Railway (SIR): The SIR light rail starts at St. George station and runs the length of Staten Island south to Tottenville. It's included in the OMNY/MetroCard fare and connects to the ferry at St. George.
- Express buses: The SIM1, SIM3, SIM4, and other express buses from St. George reach Midtown Manhattan directly, bypassing the ferry+subway transfer — particularly useful for destinations in midtown east or west.
- Driving: The Verrazzano-Narrows Bridge connects Staten Island to Brooklyn (and onward to Manhattan). Traffic can be heavy during rush hour, and the bridge toll applies in one direction.
Who Lives in St. George?
St. George has a notably diverse population for Staten Island — more racially and ethnically mixed than the borough's more suburban southern neighborhoods. You'll find long-term Italian-American and Irish-American residents alongside growing communities from Sri Lanka, West Africa, Mexico, and Central America. The neighborhood also has an increasing population of young creative professionals drawn by low rents, waterfront views, and improving cultural amenities.
The ferry commute self-selects for people with a certain tolerance for the water crossing — and a willingness to accept the geographic separation from Manhattan that comes with island living. Those who embrace it tend to find Staten Island's slower pace and more spacious living conditions a genuine quality-of-life improvement. St. George specifically attracts renters who want proximity to the ferry and don't want to deal with a car, making it the most transit-oriented address on Staten Island.
Pros & Cons of Living in St. George
Pros
- Free 25-minute ferry to lower Manhattan — unbeatable transit value
- Spectacular harbor views of Manhattan skyline
- Significantly lower rents than comparable commute-distance neighborhoods
- Growing arts and cultural scene anchored by St. George Theatre
- 24/7 ferry service — no curfew on your social life
- Staten Island Railway provides island-wide connectivity
- Less crowded and quieter than inner-city neighborhoods
Cons
- Total Midtown commute is 50–65 minutes door-to-desk
- Borough isolation — visiting Brooklyn or Queens requires significant travel
- Limited nightlife, restaurants, and late-night options
- Car almost essential for exploring rest of Staten Island
- Ferry delays and disruptions occasionally affect reliability
- Feels very disconnected from mainstream NYC social life
Frequently Asked Questions
See how far your St. George salary goes after NYC, state, and federal taxes.
Calculate Your NYC Take-Home Pay